Precedents at Captains' Meetings
Given that most captains are undergraduates, knowledge of recent discussions and attitudes adopted to recurring problems are often non-existent. This page is a brief summary of what takes up the most time at CMs.
Eligibility of large proportions of people
The same discussion arises every few years over a different group of people:
- Said Business School - resolved when SBS became a bona-fide institute of the University of Oxford
- OXILP - resolved when the institute, which had part-Oxford and part-Brookes BR affiliation, became part of Oxford Brookes University
- Post-docs - as of the last discussion in TT11, the majority of post-docs are not members of OURCs as defined by C6.1
The main reason for it getting discussed is that a few colleges would like to have them row in their first VIII, despite not having (at the time) appropriate collegiate status. The captains' meetings notes are full of the arguments against - that it would introduce a large pool of new rowers that would displace ''home-grown'' undergraduates and post-grads; that the core principle of bumps racing being collegiate would be violated; that academic ties and employment procedures for non-academic staff are inhomogenous - the list goes on.
Don't propose a motion like this unless you have read through the ample backstory!
"We don't have a cox or enough rowers for our first boat"
This is a problem that requires you to think ahead. To paraphrase Judy Gleen, if you don't have enough rowers or coxes, you should be training some more up as an urgent priority. Many, many honorary membership requests get proposed during pre-Bumps captains' meetings. If you propose such a motion, prepare to be grilled on the following:
- When did you discover that you didn't have enough people?
- What about rowers from your second boat?
- If the answer is "they don't want to do it", then have you thought about training less? Having 8 people that all train together x times a week is a privilege and an advantage, not a right.
- What did you do about the problem when you knew about it?
- What link has the person you are proposing have with your college?
Bikes on the towpath
Bikes on the towpath are banned on Saturday of Summer Eights. There is a strict £50 fine for any college participant disobeying the rule. Anu shed some light on the current system (link):
|Ever since a member of the public complained to the Proctors about being hit by a cyclist during Eights some years back we've had...
Trust me, it's better than any of the alternatives.
Some old discussion on the extremely rare case where C is chasing B who is chasing A. B is on the other side of the river to the other boats. There is overlap but no row-past. C manages to bump A. What should happen?
http://www.ourcs.org.uk/forums/G/8293 sheds some light.
The current thought is that no bump occurred, since each boat is only liable to be bumped at a given moment by the crew that is directly in front or directly behind that is still racing.